臺大課程網

英文溝通與批判思維:研究、科技與社會的當前挑戰

114-2 開課
  • 流水號

    54886

  • 課號

    Write7021

  • 課程識別碼

    Q01 M0630

  • 無分班

  • 3 學分
  • 選修

    寫作教學中心

      選修
    • 寫作教學中心

  • 柯凱彣
  • 四 6, 7, 8
  • 共405

  • 2 類

  • 修課總人數 22 人

    本校 20 人 + 外校 2 人

  • 無領域專長

  • 英文授課
  • NTU COOL
  • 備註

    本課程以英語授課。

  • 修課限制
    • 限碩士班以上

  • 本校選課狀況

    已選上
    0/20
    外系已選上
    0/0
    剩餘名額
    0
    已登記
    0
  • 課程概述
    This course will help students develop their skills in critical thinking, logical writing, and persuasive speaking as we investigate current issues in research, technology, and society. Specifically, this course will look at the following: 1. How written media presents opinions and arguments, and how to analyze and critique their effectiveness in logically persuading an audience 2. How do published research articles justify the need or importance of the research, the validity of their findings, and the logical mistakes that these articles can make 3. How debates on technology are structured and discussed, and how to effectively express your own position on these topics Under the theme of research, technology, and society, this course offers practical, hands-on training in critical thinking and logical writing, skills essential for success in both undergraduate and graduate studies. Students will engage in a variety of activities, including analyzing real-world research articles, evaluating everyday arguments in media and society, and participating in structured debates and presentations. These activities and assignments are designed to help students identify flaws in reasoning, construct clear and persuasive arguments, and effectively communicate their ideas in both written and oral formats. By integrating debates, presentations, and cohesive writing techniques, the course prepares students for the demands of academic research, professional communication, and real-world problem-solving. This multifaceted approach builds a strong foundation for academic excellence and equips students with the confidence and clarity to express their positions and point out flaws in reasoning.
  • 課程目標
    Core Competencies (CC): Upon completion of this course, students will be able to demonstrate CC 1: Critical Analysis of Arguments CC 2: Logical Writing and Persuasion CC 3: Cohesion and Flow in Written Communication CC 4: Debate and Oral Presentation Skills CC 5: Evidence-Based Reasoning CC 6: Collaborative Critique and Peer Review Course Objective—Course Intended Learning Outcome (CILO): Upon completion of the course, students will be able to CILO 1: Critically evaluate and analyze a variety of texts to identify underlying assumptions, logical fallacies, and the strengths and weaknesses of arguments (CC 1, 5) CILO 2: Compose clear, coherent, and persuasive written arguments that are well-organized and demonstrate smooth narrative flow (CC 2, 3) CILO 3: Develop and deliver effective oral arguments and participate in structured debates to articulate ideas and respond to counterarguments (CC 4, 6) CILO 4: Apply evidence-based reasoning to integrate relevant research and data into both written and oral arguments (CC 1, 2, 5) CILO 5: Engage in collaborative critique and peer review sessions to offer constructive feedback and refine both written and oral communication skills (CC 6)
  • 課程要求
    1. Attendance on enrollment day is mandatory for this class. If you do not attend on the first day your place will be given away. 2. Lectures and materials are presented in English. You will need to have a confident level of English to successfully participate in this course. 3. Group discussions, however, can be conducted in any language. Although, if you want to improve or keep up with your English speaking, it is highly recommended that you speak in English in your groups. 4. This course is specifically designed to students who have not yet begun a research project, such as undergraduates. This course especially welcomes undergraduates from any discipline. Graduate students are also welcome. No auditors allowed. 5. Attendance is required and will be taken on most days. Being absent four times or more in a single term may cause one to fail this course. After the 3rd absence, your grade will be reduced by 1 letter grade for each additional absence. (Example: B- to C+) 6. Students are expected to arrive to class on time and to leave only after the end of class. Students who arrive late or leave early may have their final course grade reduced 7. Attendance will be taken approximately 5 minutes after class/tutorial begins. If you are late, speak to the TA for your attendance to be recorded. If you arrive 10 minutes after class/tutorial begins, you will be considered absent.
  • 預期每週課前或/與課後學習時數
    There will be assigned readings and tasks for most classes. The amount of time that these tasks will take will vary from student to student, however, in general, expect about 1-2 hours of work every week. As we approach major assignments, such as debates and presentations, your workload may increase. How much your work increase will also vary from student to student. However, fewer tasks will be assigned leading up to major assignments
  • Office Hour
    *此 Office Hour 需要提前預約
  • 指定閱讀
    - Ahmad, N., Fazal, H., Ayaz, M., Abbasi, B. H., Mohammad, I., & Fazal, L. (2011). Dengue fever treatment with Carica papaya leaves extracts. Asian Pacific Journal of Tropical Biomedicine, 1(4), 330–333. https://doi.org/10.1016/s2221-1691(11)60055-5 - AlShebli, B., Makovi, K., & Rahwan, T. (2020). Retracted article: The association be-tween early career informal mentorship in academic collaborations and Junior Au-thor Performance. Nature Communications, 11(1). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-19723-8 - Bohannon, J., Koch, D., Homm, P., & Driehaus, A. (2015). Chocolate with High Co-coa Content as a Weight-Loss Accelerator. Journal of Medical Research/the Journal of Medical Research, 15(2). https://www.medicalresearchjournal.org/index.php/GJMR/article/view/922 - Tatem, A. J., Guerra, C. A., Atkinson, P. M., & Hay, S. I. (2004). Momentous sprint at the 2156 Olympics? Nature, 431(7008), 525. https://doi.org/10.1038/431525a
  • 參考書目
    - Barnet, S., Bedau, H. A., & O'Hara, J. (2020). Current issues and enduring ques-tions: A guide to critical thinking and argument, with readings. Bedford/St. Mar-tins. - Cooper, S., & Patton, R. (2015). Writing logically, thinking critically. Pearson. - Deane, R. (2015). Make your writing flow: A practical guide to transitional words & phrases. Innerscape Publishing. - Frau-Meigs, D., & Corbu, N. (2024). Disinformation debunked: Building resilience through media and information literacy (1st ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003387404 - Moore, B. N., & Parker, R. (2011). Critical thinking. McGraw-Hill Humanities/Social Sciences/Languages. - Morrow, D. R., & Weston, A. (2019). A workbook for arguments: A complete course in critical thinking. Hackett Publishing Company. - Oh, K. E., & Tang, R. (2024). Smartphones, current events, and mobile information behavior: Consuming, reacting, sharing, and connecting through news. Routledge. - Topping, R. N. S. (2016). The elements of rhetoric: How to write and speak clearly and persuasively: A guide for students, teachers, politicians & preachers. Angelico Press. - Webb, G. P. (2021). Error and fraud: The dark side of biomedical research (1st ed.). CRC Press. https://doi.org/10.1201/9781003032670
  • 評量方式
    15%

    Assignments

    A variety of homework assignments that range from critical analysis of a document, to the composition and revision of arguments.

    30%

    Debates

    Students will work in groups to prepare for 2 complete debates. Each debate will involve orally presenting and defending their arguments. In addition, students will be evaluating and criticizing their opponent’s arguments

    20%

    Written Assignments

    Students will compose and revise two writing assignments. - Group/individual paper. Write a persuasive proposal regarding some proposed solution to a problem. This writing assignment will involve identifying a problem and researching possible solutions to that problem. Students will then structure their proposal based on the Message Box approach as designed by COMPASS Science Communication

    20%

    Lifeboat Presentation

    Students will present a persuasive group presentation - Lifeboat presentation. Students will present an oral version of their lifeboat paper, meant at being persuasive through oral expression

    10%

    Quizzes

    A variety of quizzes over the course of the semester to motivate students to retain class content and demonstrate skills covered in class

    5%

    Classroom participation

    Based on students’ participation in class discussions and learning tasks and their attendance.


    1. 本校尚無訂定 A+ 比例上限。
    2. 本校採用等第制評定成績,學生成績評量辦法中的百分制分數區間與單科成績對照表僅供參考,授課教師可依等第定義調整分數區間。詳見 學習評量專區
  • 針對學生困難提供學生調整方式
  • 補課資訊
  • 課程進度
    2/26第 1 週- Course Introduction - What is Critical Thinking? - Introduction to Critical thinking: Conclusion and Premise
    3/05第 2 週- Cohesion and Progression Patterns - Logical connectors - Identifying Conclusion and Premise(s)
    3/12第 3 週- Cohesion and Progression Patterns: Continued - Critiquing arguments
    3/19第 4 週- Article Analysis - Logical Fallacies - Persuasive Writing
    3/26第 5 週- Debate Structure - How to deliver oral arguments - Persuasive Writing: Message Box Approach
    4/02第 6 週- Debate workshop - Persuasive Writing Workshop - Logical Fallacies: Continued
    4/09第 7 週Debate 1
    4/16第 8 週- Academic Journal Article Analysis - Obscurity in writing and communication
    4/23第 9 週- Language and sensitive topics
    4/30第 10 週- Developing and sup-porting opinions - Logical transitions and connectors
    5/07第 11 週- Probability and specificity
    5/14第 12 週- Supporting arguments with examples and statistics
    5/21第 13 週- Delivering oral arguments
    5/28第 14 週- Semester Review
    6/04第 15 週- Debate workshop
    第 16 週Debate 2